"Buy the gun, not the story"

[SPEEDGUNNER]

Here is a perfect example of "Buy the gun, not the story"...this is wrong on some many accounts...

http://www.gunbroker.com/item/633684773

[Sunray]

Pop didn't buy that rifle in 1944. Don't think anybody could ever buy a rifle directly from any 'Depot' either.
Type 3 sights is from much later S/N's too. "8-44" isn't September it's August.
Col. Earl McFarland(“SA/E.McF.”) was only there until 1943. Mind you, LCol. George A. Woody("SA G.A.W..") was there in 1944.

[Rick B]

Love the Super FAKE GAW stamping. What a Turd. Rick B

[2111]

The receiver is clearly marked as a 1964 LEAD rebuild. He said "The owner’s father, who lived in Carlisle, Pennsylvania, inspected this rifle at Letterkenny Army Depot (LEAD) and was able to purchase it. Feel free to Email any questions." I don't know the seller but he does have a good history. He may not know much about M1's and is going by what the owner has told him. As Rick said, the cartouche is a fake and that butt plate sure shows a lot more use than appears on the wood and rifle. I would agree that it seems unlikely anyone could buy a rifle from Letterkenny. These rifles were still U.S. Government property and being overhauled at Letterkenny on a Govt. contract.

[dryheat]

And that's a ridiculous amount of money to ask for 99% of the Garands out there, rebuilds(that I like) included.

[ww2eyes]

Yes but i also feel the story behind the gun is also important.

[S.A. Boggs]

Yes but i also feel the story behind the gun is also important.
There is the story and then there is the truth...I prefer the truth not the Grand Dad brought it home from WWII and the serial number's don't match the date.
Sam

[TSimonetti]

Yes but i also feel the story behind the gun is also important.

The story, even if plausible, has been rendered completely irrelevant because of an ill-advised and sloppy attempt to restore the rifle to it's correct "as manufactured" configuration. True rebuild fanatics who would willingly pay $1,000+ for an unmessed with LEAD would not even consider this rifle.

[1-12 INF (M)]

If you don't like that GAW stock, surely he'll make up a EMcF or GHS to order....

[S.A. Boggs]

If you don't like that GAW stock, surely he'll make up a EMcF or GHS to order....
Now why didn't I think of that. Isn't there a guy in Georgia that can replicate most stamps?
Sam

[rockisle1903]

Rifle is for sale from "HUMPER" McBride a known purveyor of fraud k98's, I see he has branched out to U.S. rifles...He's a clown...

[2111]

Rifle is for sale from "HUMPER" McBride a known purveyor of fraud k98's, I see he has branched out to U.S. rifles...He's a clown...

Guess that also tells you not to BUY G.B. feedback. Looking at the feedback I would have felt fairly safe dealing with him. Thanks for the heads up.

[Rick B]

Guess that also tells you not to BUY G.B. feedback. Looking at the feedback I would have felt fairly safe dealing with him. Thanks for the heads up.


Folks many time do not want a mark on their Feedback as they guy will give you one. Very sad. Rick B

[dhuze]

Guess that also tells you not to BUY G.B. feedback. Looking at the feedback I would have felt fairly safe dealing with him. Thanks for the heads up.

I pay more attention to negative feedback than I do positive ones. It's easier to weed through the BS bad feedback than it is through the good ones.

[2111]

I pay more attention to negative feedback than I do positive ones. It's easier to weed through the BS bad feedback than it is through the good ones.

I would agree with you if there is enough negative feedback to see a pattern developing but in the case of this seller, 100 positive and 0 negative in last 12 months, all looked good.