Revolver vs. Pistol for CCW

[RED]

This is not a revolver vs. pistol argument, it is what you can do with it that counts. For years I carried a HK USPC .40 with a laser. I carried it in a IWB holster or loose in my jeans pocket The problem was that being handicapped, I was never going to win a quick draw contest. Somebody asked me could I shoot the HK while it was still in my jeans pocket. So, I tried it and yes you can fire one round... but that is about it. I bought a S&W 838 .38 special and it will fire all 5 rounds while still in the pocket.

What is best for you me not be the best for you. The little S&W in my jeans is a no brainer. I recently lost 50 pounds and had some jeans I was never going to wear again. I practiced with a 7 yard torso target. I can get 5 hits center mass and the pistol never leaves my pocket...

The HK USPC is a world class pistol... The S&W 838 is just a reliable easy to carry piece.

[Clark Howard]

I carry a S&W Model 60 in my jeans pocket. I can put one in the center at 7 yds much quicker than I can with my Sig from a holster. And, there is no brass to police if you have to fire in a compromising situation. Regards, Clark

[Allen]

I carry a S&W Model 60 in my jeans pocket. I can put one in the center at 7 yds much quicker than I can with my Sig from a holster. And, there is no brass to police if you have to fire in a compromising situation. Regards, Clark

I'm on the same page with you. I carry a Rossi M88 stainless. Tit for tat very similar to the Smith at a lesser price and are surprisingly accurate along with no large adjustable rear sight to catch on a holster or pocket. I own 4 of them and one Taurus 85 Ultra-Lite. I will not carry or trust ANY auto pistol for self defense, not even a 1911 (which I have 8 of). I will get a lot of flak from the devoted Glock and Sig owners but you are only halfway guaranteed one shot from an auto. After that they can and will eventually jam. A revolver is not going to jam period. If there is a misfire just pull the trigger again and go to the next cartridge. BTW I own Glocks too.

[JB White]

My preference has always been revolvers therefore they are second nature to me. Yes, I can get more used to an auto with practice, practice, practice, and I can handle most autos quite well. Under controlled circumstances. The revolver is second nature to me now, today.

[S.A. Boggs]

Revolvers Can Jam, I saw this on the firing line. In the old day's cop's were notorious for not maintaining their pdw's. I have always used a shoulder holster @ first for my 1911 and now my Sig P220. It boils down to how much maintance is a shootest willing to do. It is easier to clear a round out of the chamber then a jammed cylinder.
Sam

[dave]

Very rare for revolver to 'jam', odds much higher with a semi! And then there is the safety issue.

[Jiminvirginia]

Small Rock Island .38 snubbie revolver works for me. Fits and carries well in a IWB. Safety? Personally I think semi autos are safer, or at least easier to put in a safer condition. With an empty chamber and no magazine a semi is safe but I can insert a mag and rack a slide in a second or two if neeeded in an emergency.

[PWC]

Question...what about the side blast from the cyclinder-barrel gap? I have always taught and demonstrated the side blast to students as to why they should not stand beside the revolver when it is fired. Now, shooting from a pocket...isn't that getting a little close for 'personal' comfort from lead shavings or scorched nickers?

[S.A. Boggs]

Question...what about the side blast from the cyclinder-barrel gap? I have always taught and demonstrated the side blast to students as to why they should not stand beside the revolver when it is fired. Now, shooting from a pocket...isn't that getting a little close for 'personal' comfort from lead shavings or scorched nickers?

It's called burn your hide which never happens in the movies.
Sam

[aintright]

Question...what about the side blast from the cyclinder-barrel gap? I have always taught and demonstrated the side blast to students as to why they should not stand beside the revolver when it is fired. Now, shooting from a pocket...isn't that getting a little close for 'personal' comfort from lead shavings or scorched nickers?

Would depend on clothes as to how close the action actually is to the valuables . In practice I would assume one would wear some extra layers of protection . Never tried it from the pocket , just some thoughts on the subject . Used to be nothing but a revolver for me , finally in the 90's I tried some semi's , after getting used to them settled on a G-30 in a paddle holster , works pretty slick for me . Like it because it doesn't have any snag points and if time is allowed for an aimed shot these little pistols are incredibally accurate also with a G-21 magazine in it , it fits my hands really well .
As for the wheel gun , still carry one now and then , for personal , a snubby 38 loaded with Federal 158gr HP semi wadcutter +P , also very accurate .
I keep looking for a nice 44 special snubby , don't know why , just always wanted one .
Kenneth

[Ltdave]

Colt's Cobra FTW

only 1/8" thicker than a J-frame Smith...

6 shots...

bobbed hammer for snag free-ness...

lighter so it doesnt pull my pants down (ive got snake hips so i need my belt 3 notches tighter than is comfortable to keep my pants up with any added weight)...

[jon_norstog]

My preference has always been revolvers therefore they are second nature to me. Yes, I can get more used to an auto with practice, practice, practice, and I can handle most autos quite well. Under controlled circumstances. The revolver is second nature to me now, today.

I go with the revolver any day.

jn

[S.A. Boggs]

Much conversation revolver vs auto, that will never change. Now comes to how do you carry your PDW, spare ammo. How often do you do a complete cleaning to get rid of the "cobwebs" that accumulate i.e. clothes reside, dust and the like. I prefer a modified shoulder holster that I can on my left side carry my Sig P220/small can of pepper spray and on the other 4 loaded mags. This is my year round carry and quite comfortable.
Sam

[JB White]

Now comes to how do you carry your PDW, spare ammo.

Speed Strip with just five rounds back in the day*. A very flat fit inside any pocket. Strips may be slower, but at least you have them with you when a Speedloader isn't convenient to carry. Also, a strip may lose a round but not all 5 or 6 at once.
*_______________For numerous reasons I have opted not to carry anymore. Let's just say I don't make a habit of.

[lyman]

60's vintage S&W Centennial, mostly,

will have a spare HKS speedloader in a pocket, or if in the car, console

also carry a Seecamp LWS32 on occasion,

when it is much cooler I'll have a 1911 on the hip, or a SIG220