Titanic mission

Collapse
X
 
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts
  • 5thDragoons
    Super Moderator
    • Apr 2023
    • 652

    #1

    Titanic mission

    Still no sign of the sub and not a lot of air left. That can't be a good feeling! SW
  • Art
    Senior Member, Deceased
    • Dec 2009
    • 9256

    #2
    Originally posted by 5thDragoons
    Still no sign of the sub and not a lot of air left. That can't be a good feeling! SW
    Assuming there wasn't a catastrophic failure of the pressure hull, in which case they're all already dead, the best scenario is they-re bobbing around on the surface somewhere and unable to communicate. If they're stuck on the bottom, and they find them, they are still in deep, deep trouble. No rescue has been made below 1,500 feet and they're about 10,000 feet deeper.

    High rent adventuring that involves stuff like deep water submersibles or rocket ships is extremely dangerous by definition. People doing this should be warned that in the event of a problem there is a good chance of not surviving the trip. You truly pay your money and take your chances.
    Last edited by Art; 06-20-2023, 06:27.

    Comment

    • lyman
      Administrator - OFC
      • Aug 2009
      • 11268

      #3
      read the same and saw a short vid saying similar to what Art mentioned,

      they are crushed, from a failure in the hull, or maybe bobbing around on the surface waiting to be found,

      vid said there were several redundancies ,

      regardless, they cannot open or vent from the inside, so they may be on the surface and still suffocate,



      Comment

      • Allen
        Moderator
        • Sep 2009
        • 10583

        #4
        I think a lot of people would agree with me. I truly hope somehow these folks are alive and can be rescued but also that this ends the entertainment attraction to visit the Titanic. Finding the ship, taking pictures, and seeing that it broke up before sinking is all fine and good---a lot of questions answered there but I wish the location had never been revealed. It should be considered an unfortunate grave site and left alone.

        Comment

        • Merc
          Senior Member
          • Feb 2016
          • 1690

          #5
          Good post. Agree 100%

          Some people find pleasure in living on the edge. No one questions the motives of adventurers who choose to attempt to climb Mt. Everest, yet its slopes are littered with the bodies of those who failed to survive the climb. They were left where they fell and are not considered recoverable.

          Comment

          • Major Tom
            Very Senior Member - OFC
            • Aug 2009
            • 6181

            #6
            As I post this (7:45 am June 22), the air in the submersible has run out! Experts say now there is no hope for survivers! It is now a search for the sub!

            Comment

            • Allen
              Moderator
              • Sep 2009
              • 10583

              #7
              Old news now but a debris field was found this morning near the Titanic. So, everyone no doubt died instantly as soon as contact was lost.

              What could have gone wrong in a plastic tube with 6500psi of water surrounding you?

              Though the Titanic is in international waters the U.S., Canada, UK, France and all others that helped in the search and have rescue vessels should announce "no more sight seeing trips".

              https://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/art...r-Titanic.html

              Plastic has definite limits. I hope no one has to discover this again with production of the Boeing 787 and Airbus A350 plastic planes.

              Comment

              • Art
                Senior Member, Deceased
                • Dec 2009
                • 9256

                #8
                Originally posted by Allen
                Old news now but a debris field was found this morning near the Titanic. So, everyone no doubt died instantly as soon as contact was lost.

                What could have gone wrong in a plastic tube with 6500psi of water surrounding you?

                Though the Titanic is in international waters the U.S., Canada, UK, France and all others that helped in the search and have rescue vessels should announce "no more sight seeing trips".

                https://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/art...r-Titanic.html

                Plastic has definite limits. I hope no one has to discover this again with production of the Boeing 787 and Airbus A350 plastic planes.
                I have heard these folks talked about as "explorers" and a couple of the people on board were that but the rest were "adventure tourists" and very high rent adventure tourists indeed. We're lucky there aren't more dead folks down there. They talked to one old boy who went down on a Russian MIR submersiable which is an actual military vehicle good to 20,000 feet and is much more robust and capable than the commercial deep sea tourist mobile these folks died on. Anyway he said a current caught them and slammed them into the Titanic's screws and they caught between the props and the hull with chunks of rusty steel raining down on them. He said only the cool head of "Victor" the Rooskie driving the MIR who was a former MiG pilot kept them from being dead down there as well.

                Tourist rocketry and deep submersible diving is incredibly dangerous. No child should ever be allowed on one of these trips but not only was a kid on this one, he wasn't the first but hopefully will be the last. To the companies credit I do understand they told the clients that this trip could be your last trip and you need to know that going in. To the companies discredit they apparently waited hours before calling the cavalry. It wouldn't have made any difference but something besides corporate damage control should be on one's mind at a time like that.

                And, Allen, you're right, the wreck ought to be designated a grave site and all tourist or commercial exploitation stopped.
                Last edited by Art; 06-22-2023, 01:05.

                Comment

                • 5thDragoons
                  Super Moderator
                  • Apr 2023
                  • 652

                  #9
                  Years from now the same thing will happen with people paying way too much money to walk on the moon - or other space adventure. SW

                  Comment

                  • dryheat
                    Senior Member
                    • Sep 2009
                    • 10587

                    #10
                    I can't watch free style rock climbing and climbing Everest just seems crazy.
                    If I should die before I wake...great,a little more sleep.

                    Comment

                    • dogtag
                      Senior Member
                      • Sep 2009
                      • 14985

                      #11
                      You don't "Climb" Everest any more - you just walk up the steps holding onto the rope.

                      Comment

                      • Johnny P
                        Senior Member
                        • Aug 2009
                        • 6258

                        #12
                        Heard this on the news, and found this.

                        "Former passenger on Titan submersible says you have to sign a waiver that mentions death 3 times on the first page: 'So it's never far from your mind'
                        Last edited by Johnny P; 06-22-2023, 06:11.

                        Comment

                        • Johnny P
                          Senior Member
                          • Aug 2009
                          • 6258

                          #13
                          If you die on Everest you become you become a roadside attraction.

                          "Green Boots" isn't taking a nap.

                          [/url]

                          - - - Updated - - -
                          Last edited by Johnny P; 06-22-2023, 06:22.

                          Comment

                          • Allen
                            Moderator
                            • Sep 2009
                            • 10583

                            #14
                            Originally posted by Johnny P
                            Heard this on the news, and found this.

                            "Former passenger on Titan submersible says you have to sign a waiver that mentions death 3 times on the first page: 'So it's never far from your mind'
                            Yes, this was not just a reminder but a release from being sued if something did happen. Still, the company owners can be sued/fined/arrested/whatever due to being warned by many that this vessel was not safe enough to withstand the pressures and make this kind of trip.

                            Some who took a trip before commented that they feared they would make it out alive. The only controls on the sub was an "off the shelf" then modified Logitech game controller. The pilot received text messages from above water level and steered accordingly---read it many times and still don't understand much of it.

                            One previous employee was fired when he spoke of his concerns of safety. Not of the nature of the trip but that of the sub structure/design.

                            Long story short: it wasn't built like the Russian MIR and came no where close.

                            Comment

                            • dryheat
                              Senior Member
                              • Sep 2009
                              • 10587

                              #15
                              Kind of ironic. "Unsinkable ships" that are pretty fragile it turns out.
                              If I should die before I wake...great,a little more sleep.

                              Comment

                              Working...