Do these swords have any value.

Collapse
X
 
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts
  • Hecklerusp45
    Senior Member
    • Apr 2010
    • 1174

    #1

    Do these swords have any value.

    Found a couple of swords for sale online. Anyone here think they have any value or is the condition too bad?jap 1.jpgjap 2.jpgjap 3.jpgsword.jpg
    "In God We Trust"
  • Guamsst
    Senior Member
    • Nov 2010
    • 9753

    #2
    The one in the first three pics is a bad fake out of China. They were selling these on ebay with misleading photos and really expensive shipping($100+), but a low price ($5-$10). When the buyer complained after receiving a bad fake they would gladly refund the purchase price of $5-$10. Don't ask how I know this, I don't want to talk about it...lol

    The one propped up in the corner may be a legitimate sabre, possibly US civil war era, or European from mid 1800s-1900. In that condition, could be anywhere from $30-$300. Depends on what it actually is....IF IT IS REAL.
    I own firearms not to fight against my government, but to ensure I will not have to.

    Comment

    • Ken The Kanuck
      Very Senior Member - OFC
      • Aug 2009
      • 4094

      #3
      I have one of the Japanese ones, truly amazing just how much trouble they go to. The scabbord (sp?) is made from wooden slats and wrapped in copper or brass with a bunch of design. The one I have has no edge on the blade, maybe a 1/8" wide.

      I too was suckered on Ebay.

      KTK

      Comment

      • robh5
        Senior Member
        • Sep 2011
        • 139

        #4
        The one in the corner looks like a M1840 heavy cav.saber import for the Civil War. It's in poor condition, and missing scabbard $150 max on a good day.

        Comment

        • Hecklerusp45
          Senior Member
          • Apr 2010
          • 1174

          #5
          Thanks for the good info guys, I think I will pass on them.
          "In God We Trust"

          Comment

          • Guamsst
            Senior Member
            • Nov 2010
            • 9753

            #6
            Originally posted by Ken The Kanuck
            I too was suckered on Ebay.

            KTK
            Glad I am not the only one....lol
            Sadly, there were some good honest dealers out of China with good stuff at one time. They were swallowed by a Banzai attack of BS though.

            At one time I was buying grenade parts of a Chinese seller. He had great items and only one very angry negative feedback -"I BOUGHT AN INERT GRENADE AND WHEN IT ARRIVED IT WAS A LIVE GRENADE! NOT COOL!!!!!" I should have saved a screenshot of that feedback. Seeing it actually caused me to bid on more of his stuff. I figured anyone who could get live grenades probably had no trouble getting the shipping plugs, caps and pins I wanted. I kind of wonder what happened to him, ran out of items, accident, Chinese prison?
            I own firearms not to fight against my government, but to ensure I will not have to.

            Comment

            • joem
              Senior Member, Deceased
              • Aug 2009
              • 11835

              #7
              yikes a live one!!!!

              Comment

              Working...