Critique

[Vern Humphrey]

The question is not, "Has anyone at this forum posted an endorsement of such an idea?" but rather are there people on this forum who will not speak out against such an idea.

Those who stand in silence give tacit approval.

[togor]

The question is not, "Has anyone at this forum posted an endorsement of such an idea?" but rather are there people on this forum who will not speak out against such an idea.

Those who stand in silence give tacit approval.

So if Art or bostonbound for example miss this thread, then they are assumed to approve non-citizens voting. And I notice you participate but don't taken a position yourself. I don't think such stupid rules win you any fans here, Vernon.

[Vern Humphrey]

Hee Haw!

[lyman]

I agree with this. People here on green cards, let them take the next step, an oath of allegiance to the Constitution. I would however not permit gun ownership by non-citizens, on the logic that giving a man access to a gun but not the ballot puts the cart before the horse.

you realize a green card holder (resident alien) can buy any firearm,

and a non resident alien can buy a hunting license and a shotgun or rifle,

right?

of course that would not apply to illegal aliens