Biden Supreme Court Plan

Collapse
X
 
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts
  • Art
    Senior Member, Deceased
    • Dec 2009
    • 9256

    #1

    Biden Supreme Court Plan

    I heard this floated and think it's a real possibility for proposed legislation by the Biden Supreme Court Commission.

    Basically the idea is a law that would put Supreme Court Justices on "senior status" at a certain age. At that point they would only hear cases if there was a vacancy on the court, a justice was too ill to hear the case or a justice had to recuse. This would keep the number of active justices at 9 while removing the old guys (or gals) to a very limited role while keeping their Constitutionally mandated life appointments.

    How would this work? Lets say Congress mandated a judge go to Senior Status at 75. This would give Biden two appointments at least while he's President. Breyer would go immediately and Thomas would go in June, 2023. They'd still be on the court they just wouldn't have much to do. Of course to get a real radical to replace Thomas the Dems would have to retain control of the Senate. Then there's always the possibility of Senior Status younger, lets say 70. Expanded to the whole judiciary this would open up a heck of a lot of room for Biden appointees.

    Don't be surprised if some sort of similar idea doesn't show up and advertised as a sort of back door term limitation. It sounds "reasonable" would probably pass and result in at least a couple of more Dem Supreme Court Justices.
    Last edited by Art; 04-12-2021, 06:52.
  • kj47
    Senior Member
    • Apr 2013
    • 699

    #2
    What a stupid idea! Lets hope thats all it is.

    Comment

    • Vern Humphrey
      Administrator - OFC
      • Aug 2009
      • 15875

      #3
      Just a re-do on the Roosevelt Court-Packing Scheme.

      But if 75 is "senior status" for a judge, what is senior status for a President? After all, Biden is 78.

      Comment

      • Art
        Senior Member, Deceased
        • Dec 2009
        • 9256

        #4
        Originally posted by Vern Humphrey
        Just a re-do on the Roosevelt Court-Packing Scheme.

        But if 75 is "senior status" for a judge, what is senior status for a President? After all, Biden is 78.
        Of course it's "court packing light." It's something that would allow Biden to say he's done something without triggering a catastrophic backlash.

        Federal judges routinely go on senior status but they put themselves on it as a form of semi retirement, so there is a precedent for the status, it just has never been mandatory.

        Politicians seldom vote to limit themselves, just other folks.

        Comment

        • Vern Humphrey
          Administrator - OFC
          • Aug 2009
          • 15875

          #5
          Originally posted by Art
          Of course it's "court packing light." It's something that would allow Biden to say he's done something without triggering a catastrophic backlash.

          Federal judges routinely go on senior status but they put themselves on it as a form of semi retirement, so there is a precedent for the status, it just has never been mandatory.

          Politicians seldom vote to limit themselves, just other folks.
          They're like people who decry the increasing population, but never schedule themselves for early departure.

          Comment

          Working...