Putin is picking a fight he can't win with Ukraine

Collapse
X
 
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts
  • RED
    Very Senior Member - OFC
    • Aug 2009
    • 11689

    #1

    Putin is picking a fight he can't win with Ukraine

    This Fox news reporter obviously is smoking Bull Durham. From the above headline, Robecca Grant thinks NATO would use combat forces to achieve air supremacy over Ukraine and the Black Sea.

    Really?
  • Allen
    Moderator
    • Sep 2009
    • 10625

    #2
    That's what NATO SHOULD do but not what it WILL do.

    Fox belongs to Disney now and while it is said that Disney only bought the movie network and not the news network none of us know what was agree upon or what is going on.

    Regardless, Fox news has undergone a huge transformation making one think it has become a big Mickey Mouse outfit.

    Comment

    • togor
      Banned
      • Nov 2009
      • 17610

      #3
      Look at a map.

      West of Ukraine you have Poland, Slovakia, Hungary. All NATO members but more importantly states that have no desire to be ruled once again from Moscow. There are places in the world where animosity towards the neighbors runs so much deeper than we poor dumb Americans can ever imagine. India/Pakistan is one place. The former Warsaw pact is another.

      Comment

      • RED
        Very Senior Member - OFC
        • Aug 2009
        • 11689

        #4
        Look at the aircraft available to Poland, and other neighboring nations, then consider all out war? no way NATO nations are going to risk a nuclear war to save Ukraine (or Slovodka, Poland, Hungary).

        Then look on a map at what is east of Ukraine?

        Air supremacy over Ukraine and the Black Sea is a pipe dream. Imagine US Navy launching from carriers on the Med and fighting land based aircraft from Russia. Our only air supremacy aircraft capable of competing with the newer Russian Migs is the F-22, and it is not carrier based.

        Just my honest opinion.
        Last edited by RED; 01-14-2022, 07:24. Reason: Left out.

        Comment

        • togor
          Banned
          • Nov 2009
          • 17610

          #5
          RED I can't tell if you believe Europe won't fight, don't want Europe to resist, or both. But you're placing your chips on defeatism, which says something about the bettor.

          Comment

          • Allen
            Moderator
            • Sep 2009
            • 10625

            #6
            Originally posted by RED
            Look at the aircraft available to Poland, and other neighboring nations, then consider all out war? no way NATO nations are going to risk a nuclear war to save Ukraine (or Slovodka, Poland, Hungary).

            Then look on a map at what is east of Ukraine?

            Air supremacy over Ukraine and the Black Sea is a pipe dream. Imagine US Navy launching from carriers on the Med and fighting land based aircraft from Russia. Our only air supremacy aircraft capable of competing with the newer Russian Migs is the F-22, and it is not carrier based.

            Just my honest opinion.
            I think I can safely say that no one wants to go to war with Russia and finding allies to help would be very hard regardless of what imput NATO/UN might have to say about it.

            It would also be a grand opportunity for China to chime in, support Russia and fight an already weakened adversary. The problem with secretive communist countries is you don't know what technology they have and how much of it they have. What they may lack in equipment they can well make up for it in sheer numbers.

            Both, no doubt, have countless spies living and working here and probably have contacts in congress as well.

            I feel the threat of having to fight Russia is the main reason Iran hasn't already been blown off the map by us or Israel.

            Comment

            • lyman
              Administrator - OFC
              • Aug 2009
              • 11294

              #7
              Originally posted by RED
              Look at the aircraft available to Poland, and other neighboring nations, then consider all out war? no way NATO nations are going to risk a nuclear war to save Ukraine (or Slovodka, Poland, Hungary).

              Then look on a map at what is east of Ukraine?

              Air supremacy over Ukraine and the Black Sea is a pipe dream. Imagine US Navy launching from carriers on the Med and fighting land based aircraft from Russia. Our only air supremacy aircraft capable of competing with the newer Russian Migs is the F-22, and it is not carrier based.

              Just my honest opinion.


              who says it would be a navy only job?

              cruise missiles will do the grunt work to start, followed up by sorties of either smaller craft or B2's

              we can refuel mid air, and I am sure for the right price Turkey will be our ally

              we have also recently done joint exercise's with Romania, and should still be on good terms with Hungary

              Comment

              • Vern Humphrey
                Administrator - OFC
                • Aug 2009
                • 15875

                #8
                But remember who will be our Commander in Chief and our Chairman of the Joint Chiefs of Staff.

                Comment

                • Allen
                  Moderator
                  • Sep 2009
                  • 10625

                  #9
                  Originally posted by Vern Humphrey
                  But remember who will be our Commander in Chief and our Chairman of the Joint Chiefs of Staff.
                  But he did such an excellent job of pulling out of Afghanistan.

                  Comment

                  • Vern Humphrey
                    Administrator - OFC
                    • Aug 2009
                    • 15875

                    #10
                    Originally posted by Allen
                    But he did such an excellent job of pulling out of Afghanistan.
                    When he pulls out of the Ukraine, he'll probably leave the whole Army and Airforce behind.

                    Comment

                    • dryheat
                      Senior Member
                      • Sep 2009
                      • 10587

                      #11
                      The thing that makes my eyes roll is the threat of Very Serious Sanctions. Yeah, I guess sanctions do work. I think they kind of worked with Iran. Does that really scare Russia?
                      If I should die before I wake...great,a little more sleep.

                      Comment

                      • RED
                        Very Senior Member - OFC
                        • Aug 2009
                        • 11689

                        #12
                        Originally posted by togor
                        RED I can't tell if you believe Europe won't fight, don't want Europe to resist, or both. But you're placing your chips on defeatism, which says something about the bettor.
                        Defeatism or realism? There is a bit of history you are overlooking. When is the last time Europe fought with Russia and won.

                        Of course the Navy can refuel airborne but it is over 1100 miles oneway from the Med to the Ukraine/Russia border. Turkey under Tayyip Erdoğan is not a slam dunk partner. For one thing, Turkey gets about 85% of its natural gas from Russia. All in all Turkey has a import export deficit of $90 billion and China, Russia, and Iran are three of it?s important trading partners.

                        Comment

                        • dogtag
                          Senior Member
                          • Sep 2009
                          • 14985

                          #13
                          As Obama said; "Never underestimate Biden's ability to ferk things up"

                          I just hope he doesn't make the mistake of underestimating the enemy

                          Comment

                          • one shot
                            Senior Member
                            • Jul 2021
                            • 534

                            #14
                            You ever notice the commies only pick fights they feel they can win , says something about them . If we stand up and fight they will back down what will Biden do we will see . Never forget Corn Pop was a bad dude but no match for Joe .

                            Comment

                            • Vern Humphrey
                              Administrator - OFC
                              • Aug 2009
                              • 15875

                              #15
                              We're going into action with the most incompetent leaders this country has ever produced.

                              Comment

                              Working...